Total Pageviews

Tuesday 12 July 2016

Tug of War for Limitation period for penalties not linked to assessment of Income like 271D/271E/271C imposable by Range Heads i.e. Joint Commissioners

Under Section 271D penalty is imposable by Joint Commissioner for failure to comply 269SS i.e. accepting loan or deposit for Rs. 20,000/- or more otherwise than through account payee cheque equal to amount of loan or deposit. Similarly Under Section 271E, there is penalty for repayment of the amount of loan or deposit otherwise than through account payee cheque, where loan or deposit is outstanding for Rs. 20,000 ruprees or more.

CBDT vide letter dated 11-07-2016 has provided three revised format of issuing notices u/s 143(2). 1. Limited Scrutiny 2. Complete Scrutiny 3. Mannual Scrutiny

CBDT vide letter dated 11-07-2016 has provided three revised format of issuing notices u/s 143(2).

1.       Limited Scrutiny

2.       Complete Scrutiny

3.       Mannual Scrutiny


In Limited Scrutiny, issues identified for examination to be specified. Notice for Complete scrutiny shall specify that case is selected for complete scrutiny. In case of manual scrutiny, specific parameter for selection of case along with reference to manual instruction no. of compulsory scrutiny guidelines shall be given.

Assessee is required to produce evidence in support of his return or if assesse wishes to send no evidence, he may send his communication to AO.

If on the basis of response of assesse, any adverse view is contemplated, show cause notice/questionnaire shall be given .

In case of Ahemadabad, Bengluru, Chennai, Delhi , Hyderabad , Kolkatta and  Mumbai, it is to be stated in notice that email based assessment is proposed to be made. Email id provided by assesse in return or alternate id provided by the assesse shall be used for the purpose. Assessees not wishing to opt for email based assessment may convey refusal to AO. Subsequent withdrawl from email based assessment is possible only with prior permission of AO.


Also in Instruction No. 20/2015 dated 29-12-2015, CBDT had mentioned that AO to provide reasons for scrutiny in cases which have been selected on the parameter(s) of AIR/CIB/26AS data . Further Specific issue based enquiry is to be conducted only in those scrutiny cases which have been selected on the parameter(s) of AIR/CIB/26AS data. In such cases, the Assessing Officer, shall also confine the Questionnaire only to the specific issues pertaining to AIR/CIB/26AS data

Regards Ca Vinamar Gupta